ICAS ICAS logo

Quicklinks

  1. About Us

    Find out about who we are and what we do here at ICAS.

  2. Find a CA

    Search our directory of individual CAs and Member organisations by name, location and professional criteria.

  3. CA Magazine

    View the latest issues of the dedicated magazine for ICAS Chartered Accountants.

  4. Contact Us

    Get in touch with ICAS by phone, email or post, with dedicated contacts for Members, Students and firms.

Login
  • Annual renewal
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Find a CA
  1. About us
    1. Governance
  2. Members
    1. Become a member
    2. Newly qualified
    3. Manage my membership
    4. Benefits of membership
    5. Careers support
    6. Mentoring
    7. CA Wellbeing
    8. More for Members
    9. Area networks
    10. International communities
    11. Get involved
    12. Top Young CAs
    13. Career breaks
    14. ICAS podcast
    15. Newly admitted members 2022
    16. Newly admitted members 2023
  3. CA Students
    1. Student information
    2. Student resources
    3. Learning requirements
    4. Learning updates
    5. Learning blog
    6. Totum Pro | Student discount card
    7. CA Student wellbeing
  4. Become a CA
    1. How to become a CA
    2. Routes to becoming a CA
    3. CA Stories
    4. Find a training agreement
    5. Why become a CA
    6. Qualification information
    7. University exemptions
  5. Employers
    1. Become an Authorised Training Office
    2. Resources for Authorised Training Offices
    3. Professional entry
    4. Apprenticeships
  6. Find a CA
  7. ICAS events
    1. CA Summit
  8. CA magazine
  9. Insight
    1. Finance + Trust
    2. Finance + Technology
    3. Finance + EDI
    4. Finance + Mental Fitness
    5. Finance + Leadership
    6. Finance + Sustainability
  10. Professional resources
    1. Anti-money laundering
    2. Audit and assurance
    3. Brexit
    4. Business and governance
    5. Charities
    6. Coronavirus
    7. Corporate and financial reporting
    8. Cyber security
    9. Ethics
    10. Insolvency
    11. ICAS Research
    12. Pensions
    13. Practice
    14. Public sector
    15. Sustainability
    16. Tax
  11. CPD - professional development
    1. CPD courses and qualifications
    2. CPD news and updates
    3. CPD support and advice
  12. Regulation
    1. Complaints and sanctions
    2. Regulatory authorisations
    3. Guidance and help sheets
    4. Regulatory monitoring
  13. CA jobs
    1. CA jobs partner: Rutherford Cross
    2. Resources for your job search
    3. Advertise with CA jobs
    4. Hays | A Trusted ICAS CA Jobs Partner
    5. Azets | What's your ambition?
  14. Work at ICAS
    1. Business centres
    2. Meet our team
    3. Benefits
    4. Vacancies
    5. Imagine your career at ICAS
  15. Contact us
    1. Technical and regulation queries
    2. ICAS logo request

Was the appellant due to pay output VAT under the Lennartz mechanism?

  • LinkedIn (opens new window)
  • Twitter (opens new window)
By Jan Garioch CA

28 January 2021

Main points:

  • HMRC tried to deny VAT recovery to a college which changed its view on whether it had to account for output VAT under the Lennartz mechanism.
  • The FTT had rejected the college claim and found the grants it received were not consideration for any supply of services.
  • This was reversed by the UT which found the college’s supplies had always been exempt supplies within the scope of VAT.

Jan Garioch CA discusses a recent case, Colchester Institute Corporation v HMRC, where the Upper Tribunal has to consider the fate of VAT incurred on a significant construction project for a college in receipt of finance from funding agencies.

The background to the case

Colchester Institute Corporation (CIC) is incorporated as a general further education college offering educational and vocational courses to over 11,000 students of differing ages from 16 upwards. Most of these students receive free training with the finance coming from further education funding agencies, although some students, for instance international ones who are not entitled to free education, pay fees. The agreements with the funding agencies do not stipulate which qualification a student should take but they only fund qualifications approved on a Government maintained website.

CIC started a major building project in 2008.  At that time CIC and HMRC both believed that the provision of education, when funded by a relevant funding body, was not a business activity and hence outside the scope of VAT. Consequently, under the Lennartz mechanism CIC applied for, and was granted, permission to deduct input VAT incurred on the building project and subsequently account for deemed output VAT on the provision of education services in due course. Since those services were thought to amount to non-business supplies, the tax charge arose under para 5(4) Sch4 VATA1994 and Part15A SI1995/2518. In total, £2.25M of input VAT was repaid to CIC, but it continued to account for output VAT on deemed supplies.

The origin of the VAT dispute

In 2014, CIC changed its view and claimed its supplies were after all business supplies and hence it had never needed to account for deemed output VAT on non-business supplies. It claimed repayment of the deemed output VAT subject to the 4-year cap. HMRC refused and that decision was appealed to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT).

What the FTT thought

CIC failed to convince the FTT, which decided that funding received was merely a block grant subject to conditions and did not constitute consideration for any supplies made by CIC. The FTT did not find any direct link between the cost of education provided to any specific student and the funding provided. However, CIC appealed this decision to the Upper Tribunal (UT).

Arguments put to the UT

CIC argued that the FTT had erred in law when it did not see sufficient link between the grant funding and the supply of services to students. The grant funding was paid on an ongoing basis based on a formula targeted at certain categories of students. CIC asserted that Le Rayon d’Or SARL v Ministre de l’Économie et des Finances [2014] established that lump sum payments calculated by reference to a formula could be consideration for VAT purposes. HMRC put forward the counter argument that the FTT was correct to consider whether CIC made any supply in respect of a particular course to an individual student. They asserted this was required, although they acknowledged that the identity of the particular student did not need to be known. HMRC tried to distinguish Rayon d’Or as being on different facts since it concerned the permanent availability of healthcare services to care home residents at the appropriate time. HMRC cited South African Tourist Board v Customs Commissioners [2014] UKUT 280 in support of their arguments. The South African government funded a body promoting tourism in South Africa where it was held there was no supply because there was not a mutual exchange of supply for a consideration.

The UT decision

The UT defined their task to be drawing on two previous cases with “diametrically opposite analysis” and deciding which side of the line CIC falls against that backdrop. The UT was most strongly influenced by Rayon d’Or case and found a direct link between grants coming into CIC and the courses provided to CIC students for free. They saw the experience of students who were required to pay for their tuition to be identical to that of students who were fully funded by grants. They concluded that the FTT was wrong to look for a link that was so direct that it matched supplies and/or cost of supplies to individual students because nothing in case law requires the link to be so specific.

Since CIC’s supplies were always exempt supplies, it had erred in overpaying output VAT under the Lennartz mechanism.  Similarly, HMRC had erred in not assessing in time to recover the input VAT wrongly repaid to CIC on their building project.

Ongoing consequence

This case is of consequence to other educational providers who had embarked on construction projects and have similar VAT disputes in progress. Any further appeal on this case will be closely watched.

Should taxpayer have known transactions were connected to fraud?

By Jan Garioch CA

27 November 2020

Change proposed for VAT Recovery under Section 41 VATA 1994

By Jan Garioch CA

23 October 2020

2022-11-mitigo 2022-11-mitigo
ICAS logo

Footer links

  • Contact us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Modern slavery statement
  • Privacy notice
  • CA magazine

Connect with ICAS

  • Facebook (opens new window) Facebook Icon
  • Twitter (opens new window) Twitter Icon
  • LinkedIn (opens new window) LinkedIn Icon
  • Instagram (opens new window) Instagram Icon

ICAS is a member of the following bodies

  • Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies (opens new window) Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies logo
  • Chartered Accountants Worldwide (opens new window) Chartered Accountants Worldwide logo
  • Global Accounting Alliance (opens new window) Global Accounting Alliance
  • International Federation of Accountants (opens new window) IFAC
  • Access Accountancy (opens new window) Access Acountancy

Charities

  • ICAS Foundation (opens new window) ICAS Foundation
  • SCABA (opens new window) scaba

Accreditations

  • ISO 9001 - RGB (opens new window)
© ICAS 2022

The mark and designation “CA” is a registered trade mark of The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS), and is available for use in the UK and EU only to members of ICAS. If you are not a member of ICAS, you should not use the “CA” mark and designation in the UK or EU in relation to accountancy, tax or insolvency services. The mark and designation “Chartered Accountant” is a registered trade mark of ICAS, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales and Chartered Accountants Ireland. If you are not a member of one of these organisations, you should not use the “Chartered Accountant” mark and designation in the UK or EU in relation to these services. Further restrictions on the use of these marks also apply where you are a member.

ICAS logo

Our cookie policy

ICAS.com uses cookies which are essential for our website to work. We would also like to use analytical cookies to help us improve our website and your user experience. Any data collected is anonymised. Please have a look at the further information in our cookie policy and confirm if you are happy for us to use analytical cookies: