ICAS ICAS logo

Quicklinks

  1. About Us

    Find out about who we are and what we do here at ICAS.

  2. Find a CA

    Search our directory of individual CAs and Member organisations by name, location and professional criteria.

  3. CA Magazine

    View the latest issues of the dedicated magazine for ICAS Chartered Accountants.

  4. Contact Us

    Get in touch with ICAS by phone, email or post, with dedicated contacts for Members, Students and firms.

Login
  • Annual renewal
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Find a CA
  1. About us
    1. Governance
  2. Members
    1. Become a member
    2. Newly qualified
    3. Manage my membership
    4. Benefits of membership
    5. Careers support
    6. Mentoring
    7. CA Wellbeing
    8. More for Members
    9. Area networks
    10. International communities
    11. Get involved
    12. Top Young CAs
    13. Career breaks
    14. ICAS podcast
    15. Newly admitted members 2022
    16. Newly admitted members 2023
  3. CA Students
    1. Student information
    2. Student resources
    3. Learning requirements
    4. Learning updates
    5. Learning blog
    6. Totum Pro | Student discount card
    7. CA Student wellbeing
  4. Become a CA
    1. How to become a CA
    2. Routes to becoming a CA
    3. CA Stories
    4. Find a training agreement
    5. Why become a CA
    6. Qualification information
    7. University exemptions
  5. Employers
    1. Become an Authorised Training Office
    2. Resources for Authorised Training Offices
    3. Professional entry
    4. Apprenticeships
  6. Find a CA
  7. ICAS events
    1. CA Summit
  8. CA magazine
  9. Insight
    1. Finance + Trust
    2. Finance + Technology
    3. Finance + EDI
    4. Finance + Mental Fitness
    5. Finance + Leadership
    6. Finance + Sustainability
  10. Professional resources
    1. Anti-money laundering
    2. Audit and assurance
    3. Brexit
    4. Business and governance
    5. Charities
    6. Coronavirus
    7. Corporate and financial reporting
    8. Cyber security
    9. Ethics
    10. Insolvency
    11. ICAS Research
    12. Pensions
    13. Practice
    14. Public sector
    15. Sustainability
    16. Tax
  11. CPD - professional development
    1. CPD courses and qualifications
    2. CPD news and updates
    3. CPD support and advice
  12. Regulation
    1. Complaints and sanctions
    2. Regulatory authorisations
    3. Guidance and help sheets
    4. Regulatory monitoring
  13. CA jobs
    1. CA jobs partner: Rutherford Cross
    2. Resources for your job search
    3. Advertise with CA jobs
    4. Hays | A Trusted ICAS CA Jobs Partner
    5. Azets | What's your ambition?
  14. Work at ICAS
    1. Business centres
    2. Meet our team
    3. Benefits
    4. Vacancies
    5. Imagine your career at ICAS
  15. Contact us
    1. Technical and regulation queries
    2. ICAS logo request

Mutuality of Obligation once again defeats HMRC when Upper Tribunal blows the whistle

  • LinkedIn (opens new window)
  • Twitter (opens new window)
Justine Ricommini By Justine Riccomini, Head of Taxation (Scottish Taxes, Employment and ICAS Tax Community)

19 May 2020

Main points:

  • The Upper Tribunal has determined that referees were not employees
  • Mutuality of Obligation was key to the decision
  • The decision casts doubt on the validity of HMRC’s employment status checker “CEST” tool

Justine Riccomini explains why the Upper Tax Tribunal did not concur with HMRC’s arguments in this latest employment status case concerning football referees.

Decision

Another employment status decision hit the doormat this month which makes interesting reading. It concerns a company by the name of Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) which is an entity owned jointly by the FA, the Premier League and the Football League and provides match officials for professional football matches.

First Tier (FTT)

The FTT originally heard this case in July 2018 and that decision was based upon evidence given in relation to part-time referees who officiate matches in their spare time and are not full-time employees of PGMOL. HMRC had issued determinations for significant amounts of PAYE and NICs covering two tax years (14/15 and 15/16), having decided that the referees were to be classified as employees.

Three key considerations formed the basis of the decision:

1. Mutuality of obligation (which encompasses personal service);
2. Control;
3. Evidence of an independent trade or profession.

Whilst the FTT found the existence of a contractual relationship, it concluded:

  • There was no right to appoint a substitute – something which would normally satisfy the mutuality of obligation test - but that the referees could cancel each match as it suited them.
  • Overall, there was no guarantee of work on the one side or expectation of it on the other.
  • There was not a sufficient degree of control over the referees to induce an employment relationship.
  • The referees were in sole charge and had ultimate discretion over decisions made of the matches they officiated, other than to abide by the general rules of football as set out by the FA.
  • Whilst other employment-related issues were present, these were overshadowed by the absence of mutuality of obligation.
  • The referees were not employed by PGMOL.

Upper Tribunal (UT)

The UT heard the case in January 2020 and crucially considered HMRC’s statement that “Mutuality of obligation is relevant only to the question of whether there is a contract at all…  and not to the question whether such contract is one of employment or a contract for services”.

This was rejected because in the UT’s opinion, mutuality is “an essential requirement in categorising a contract as one of employment” and thus, more than simply the provision of personal service. A wider interpretation of mutuality would be necessary. The UT upheld the interpretation of mutuality placed by the FTT.

The UT then went on to explain that in this case as mutuality was the overarching factor, it was not necessary to consider control – but it had done so for the sake of completeness and transparency. This was interesting because the UT actually concluded that the FTT had made an error of judgement in its consideration of the concept of control – but in this case it made no difference to the outcome of the case.  HMRC’s appeal was dismissed.

CEST

The HMRC “Check Employment Status for Tax” tool (CEST) has not been configured to consider the concept of mutuality for precisely the reasons stated by HMRC in the UT case above. Despite constant calls from professional bodies and other stakeholders as well as the IR35 Forum that mutuality should be included in the testing tool, and that the test is not sufficiently robust without it, it still doesn’t appear.

HMRC has been reported as saying it intends to appeal this binding decision.

Conclusion

A growing number of tax cases being heard in relation to employment status are now being found to fall down on mutuality of obligation. It remains to be seen whether HMRC employment status policy can be swayed by these judgements and change its technical stance.

Representing members views on IR35 to the House of Lords

By Charlotte Barbour, Director of Taxation

30 April 2020

2-23-marsh 2-23-marsh
ICAS logo

Footer links

  • Contact us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Modern slavery statement
  • Privacy notice
  • CA magazine

Connect with ICAS

  • Facebook (opens new window) Facebook Icon
  • Twitter (opens new window) Twitter Icon
  • LinkedIn (opens new window) LinkedIn Icon
  • Instagram (opens new window) Instagram Icon

ICAS is a member of the following bodies

  • Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies (opens new window) Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies logo
  • Chartered Accountants Worldwide (opens new window) Chartered Accountants Worldwide logo
  • Global Accounting Alliance (opens new window) Global Accounting Alliance
  • International Federation of Accountants (opens new window) IFAC
  • Access Accountancy (opens new window) Access Acountancy

Charities

  • ICAS Foundation (opens new window) ICAS Foundation
  • SCABA (opens new window) scaba

Accreditations

  • ISO 9001 - RGB (opens new window)
© ICAS 2022

The mark and designation “CA” is a registered trade mark of The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS), and is available for use in the UK and EU only to members of ICAS. If you are not a member of ICAS, you should not use the “CA” mark and designation in the UK or EU in relation to accountancy, tax or insolvency services. The mark and designation “Chartered Accountant” is a registered trade mark of ICAS, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales and Chartered Accountants Ireland. If you are not a member of one of these organisations, you should not use the “Chartered Accountant” mark and designation in the UK or EU in relation to these services. Further restrictions on the use of these marks also apply where you are a member.

ICAS logo

Our cookie policy

ICAS.com uses cookies which are essential for our website to work. We would also like to use analytical cookies to help us improve our website and your user experience. Any data collected is anonymised. Please have a look at the further information in our cookie policy and confirm if you are happy for us to use analytical cookies: